Science Media Centre

Science Media Centre

Featured

Media reports of increased earthquakes in 2018 – Expert reaction

Posted in Expert Reactions

A media report from the weekend suggests a link between the Earth’s rotation and an increase in intense earthquakes.

The report follows a conference presentation last month by two US researchers who suggest a slowing of Earth’s rotation is correlated with an increase in earthquakes of magnitude 7 or higher.

The SMC asked experts to comment on the media reports, please feel free to use these comments in your reporting.

Professor Martha Savage, Institute of Geophysics, Victoria University of Wellington, comments:

“The correlation occurs with a “phase lag” of about five years, which means that the minimum in rotation rate precedes the peak in earthquakes by about five years. Roger Bilham suggests that the correlation could be used to predict, in general, that the occurrence of earthquakes over magnitude 7 will be larger this year (and in the next five years) than it was in the previous five years.

“He also suggests two possible explanations for the correlation: the slight change in the Earth’s shape caused by the slower rotation might put extra stress on the crust, or tectonic plates may act like “a loose cannon sliding upon the deck of a rolling ship” and don’t quite keep up with the change in motion of the mantle underneath them, again causing stress to build up in the crust.”

“The next five years can therefore serve as a test of his hypothesis, but there are no specific predictions about exactly where the increased earthquakes will be. In any case, it is a good reminder to keep up to date with your earthquake preparedness in terms of making sure that you have enough water and food for a week and by checking that your belongings are appropriately fastened in case there is a large earthquake.”

Professor Mark Stirling, Chair of Earthquake Science, University of Otago, comments:

“The Otago Earthquake Science group does not support the primary conclusion of this article. We see it as yet another example of a fortuitous correlation between earthquake occurrence and an unrelated phenomenon.

“Earthquake rates fluctuate greatly around the plate boundaries of the world, and many explanations for the fluctuations have been provided over the years (e.g. Super Moon, Diurnal controls, Earth Orbit Eccentricity). While the researchers involved in this most recent work are very well known and regarded, we have no basis to support their conclusions at this time.”

GNS Science statement:

“GNS Science is unable to provide a meaningful comment on this research. It appears to be a conference presentation and very preliminary rather than peer-reviewed research, so there is no detail for us to examine.

“It is true there have been periods of elevated rates of large earthquakes in the past 100 years. However, if you go looking for correlations with other natural phenomenon, you will almost certainly find some interesting matches.”

Dr Virginia Toy, senior lecturer, Department of Geology, University of Otago, comments:

“A lot of people attempt to make statistical correlations between occurrence of natural events/hazards and other environmental phenomenon. For example, there are studies of whether earthquakes are preceded by ‘lightning’ or related to ‘solid earth tides’. Some of these yield statistically defendable correlations; others don’t. I tend to think of them in the context of Ken Ring… the man who writes about apparent statistical correlations between the phase of the Moon and the weather.

“This study… I am sure the statistical correlation is more defendable than Ken Ring’s work. However, it shouldn’t inspire panic. The story has reported the researcher’s statements in a way it sounds like we will get a jump from 6 to 20 large earthquakes per year. I don’t think this is likely.”

Dr Tim Stahl, lecturer in tectonic geology, University of Canterbury, comments:

“Professors Bilham and Bendick are respected scientists in earthquake geology and seismic risk. I would look forward to seeing this study in a peer-reviewed journal, with some reporting of the statistical tests for the significance of the observed relationships and with further consideration of potential mechanisms. As with any conference abstract or presentation, it is difficult to judge the scientific merit of the claims being made until they have undergone rigorous peer-review and additional testing by other research groups.

“It is important to note that the authors explicitly state in the abstract that the precise locations, times, or magnitudes of earthquakes cannot be predicted, even if their observations and interpretations are eventually confirmed by other researchers.”

Continue reading “Media reports of increased earthquakes in 2018 – Expert reaction

The Latest

Expert Reactions

Herbicides linked to antibiotic resistance – Expert reaction

New Zealand researchers have found the active ingredients in commonly-used weed killers can cause bacteria to be less susceptible to antibiotics.  The study builds upon research published in 2015 that found three common herbicides, including Round-up, caused E.coli and Salmonella to become less sensitive to antibiotics. The new research, published in Microbiology, investigated which ingredients were responsible and found it was the […]

In the News

Kaikōura earthquake, one year on – In the News

A year on from the November 14 7.8 magnitude earthquake that shook the upper South Island and Wellington, scientists are gathering in Marlborough to discuss what they’ve learnt from the quake. Earthquake scientists have gathered in Marlborough for the eighth annual International Workshop on Paleoseismology, Active Tectonics and Archeoseismology, which is being held in the Southern […]

Reflections On Science

Why it’s so important to mark the anniversaries of earthquakes – Ursula Cochran

As the one year anniversary of the Kaikōura earthquake nears, GNS scientist Dr Ursula Cochran writes on The Spinoff why it’s important to mark the anniversaries of earthquakes, even ones that happened 300 years ago. An excerpt (read in full): Measuring how far we’ve come as a nation in living wisely with earthquakes is a […]

Q&As

What is AMB-FUBINACA? – Expert Q&A

Yesterday, New Zealand Police confirmed 20 deaths linked to synthetic drugs since July. Most of the samples from people who had died, and those seized in raids by police, were found to contain the dangerous chemical AMB-FUBINACA. The SMC prepared this Q&A on what is known about AMB-FUBINACA. Feel free to use these comments in your reporting. Prof […]

Copyright 2017 Science Media Centre (New Zealand)

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy