Science Media Centre

Science Media Centre


Pedestrian dies in self-driving car accident – Expert Reaction

Posted in Expert Reactions

A woman has died in Arizona after being hit by an Uber self-driving car – it is reported to be the first time a pedestrian has died as a result of a self-driving car accident.

In 2016, a Tesla employee was killed while operating a self-driving car.

The Science Media Centre has asked local experts to comment on the accident.

Michael Cameron, author of an upcoming Law Foundation report on driverless vehicles in New Zealand, comments:

“Driverless vehicles will be safer than the human-controlled vehicles. Some regulation is necessary, but any regulation that slows down the adoption of driverless technology will likely cost many more lives than it saves.

“In 1896, the 45-year-old Bridget Driscoll became the first recorded pedestrian fatality to be killed by a motor vehicle. And in 2018, it appears that 49-year-old Elaine Herzberg has tragically become the first pedestrian to be killed by a driverless vehicle.

“Back in 1896, the nascent motor vehicle industry managed to avoid a regulatory backlash from the Driscoll tragedy. But these are different times. There have already been calls for tighter regulations by the director of Consumer Watchdog in the US. The irony is that, this time around, we actually have a technology that is safer than the existing technology it will replace.

“The fact the vehicle wasn’t technically driverless and had a supervising driver constantly ready to take over is a detail likely to be lost in the response, but it is extremely important. While we won’t know for sure until the investigation is complete, the supervising driver would have been a highly skilled professional, and he or she also failed to avoid Ms Herzberg.”

Professor Hossein Sarrafzadeh, Adjunct Professor, High Tech Research, Unitec, comments:

“Firstly this news has been very sad to hear and my sympathies go out to the families of those that were involved. As exciting as the development of these technologies are, accidents do happen and it is always unfortunate when human lives are impacted.

“With the rapid emergence of driverless cars and autopilot technology, such an incident was likely to occur sooner or later. The accident took place on Sunday and is the first fatal accident involving a driverless car. The cause of the accident has still not been determined and I am sure there will be greater emphasis on the safety of these systems following the investigation, however, it is important to take this single event into context when considering the overall safety of these cars, particularly in comparison to human-operated vehicles.

“The Uber autonomous car in question apparently had a driver in the front seat meant to take over in such situations of risk. In addition to safety, security is another concern that needs to be taken into consideration by the developers of such high technologies.

Continue reading “Pedestrian dies in self-driving car accident – Expert Reaction

The Latest

Expert Reactions

Cosmologist Stephen Hawking dies age 76 – Experts respond

World-renowned cosmologist and theoretical physics pioneer Stephen Hawking has died in the UK aged 76. The Science Media Centre asked physicists and those who worked with him to respond to the news. Roy Kerr, Canterbury Distinguished Professor, University of Canterbury, comments: “Stephen Hawking. Such an Incredible strength of spirit and character. I first met him […]


Brown Marmorated Stink Bug – Expert Q&A

A number of car shipments were turned away at the border last month because they were infested with Brown Marmorated Stink Bugs. The bug has spread across the globe from its original home in East Asia and is one of border security’s most wanted. The agricultural pest is not currently in the country, but MPI […]

Reflections On Science

A letter to my grandchildren – Jim Salinger

Prominent climate scientist Dr Jim Salinger has spent much of his career studying climate change – in the NZ Herald, he writes a heartfelt letter to his grandchildren. An excerpt (read in full): I studied climate change before you were born, and about the time Mum and Dad were born, and recognised when they were […]

In the News

Top researchers honoured in Prime Minister’s Science Prizes

The Prime Minister’s Science Prizes have been presented in Wellington today, awarding a total of $1 million across five categories. The top prize has been awarded to a multidisciplinary team from Plant & Food Research that helped the New Zealand kiwifruit industry recover after the discovery of the vine-killing disease Psa (Pseudomonas syringae pv. actinidiae). Plant […]

Copyright 2018 Science Media Centre (New Zealand)

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy