Science Media Centre

Science Media Centre


Audio: Science advice in the context of opposing views

Posted in Briefings

A panel discussion at the inaugural Science Advice to Governments conference in Auckland, 28-29 August, 2014.

Science advice in the context of opposing political / ideological positions


Chair: Ian Boyd (Defra, UK)

Hubert Deluyker (EFSA, EC)

Roger Pielke (US)

Gordon McBean (Canada)

Chris Tyler (UK)

Ian Chubb (Australia)

Session description:

One of the most difficult situations for science advisors to government is when evidence contradicts entrenched political (ideological) positions, whether these are within national, regional or local governments. Well established examples are seen in debates around controlled substances and public health. For instance, public health interventions that adopt an evidence-based harm reduction approach are sometimes objectionable to governments and the general public. What models of science advice giving (ex: individual experts; commissioned reports; representative committees) have worked best in participating countries?

Click below to play the audio

View slides from a related session on Day 2 of the conference

Continue reading “Audio: Science advice in the context of opposing views

Latest Post From Each Category


Audio: Science advice in situations of crisis

A panel discussion at the inaugural Science Advice to Governments conference in Auckland, 28-29 August, 2014. Science Advice in Situations of Crisis panel Speakers: Chair: Anne Glover – Chief Science Advisor to President, European Commission Yuko Harayama – Executive Member of Council for Science, Technology and Innovation, Cabinet Office of Japan Andreas Hensel – President, […]

In the News

Sheepdogs round up the rules for crowd control

Scientists have found two simple rules behind how sheepdogs manage to round up and move sheep so efficiently, which they hope can be used in designing robots for crowd control or environmental cleanup. The study, published in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface this week, involved strapping backpacks with GPS units to sheepdogs and sheep and […]

Reflections On Science

A rough guide to science advice – The Guardian

Below is an excerpt from a Guardian article published ahead of the Science Advice to Governments summit which gets underway today in Auckland as part of World Science Week (read in full here) A rough guide to science advice As scientists and policymakers gather in Auckland for a global summit on scientific advice, what lessons […]

Science Alert: Experts Respond

WHO report criticises e-cigarettes – experts respond

The World Health Organization (WHO) has released a report looking at electronic cigarettes and how they should be globally regulated. The report recommended restrictions should be placed on the marketing of the devices, their sale to minors and indoor use. In addition, it points out that there is evidence showing that e-cigarette aerosol is not merely “water […]

Copyright 2014 Science Media Centre (New Zealand)

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy