Science Media Centre

Science Media Centre


Marine Protected Area definition too loose – Expert reaction

Posted in Science Alert: Experts Respond

Countries should move away from establishing ‘Marine Protected Areas’ (MPAs) with varying limits on fishing activity and focus on clear cut ‘no-take’ marine reserves, say New Zealand marine biologists.

Fish ballProf Mark Costello and Dr Bill Ballantine from the University of Auckland’s Leigh Marine Lab outlined the argument in a new article published in the journal Trends in Ecology and Evolution.

The authors say that the wide range of what constitutes a MPA makes the term meaningless from a conservation perspective.

“MPAs are often multiple-use, with the aim of managing resources rather than preserving and protecting biodiversity in its wild condition,” Dr Ballantine said in a media release.

“Only areas that are no-take should be regarded as truly protecting ocean ecosystems and if countries can’t accurately report from no-take areas within MPAs, then conservation gain should be assumed to be zero.”

You can read more about the article here.

The SMC collected the following expert commentary.

Prof Mark Orams, Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences, AUT University, comments:

“There is a danger of creating ‘paper parks’ with the widespread designation of MPAs where little to no real protection for marine resources actually occurs. Full protection ‘no-take’ marine reserves are not only a proven marine conservation strategy, they also provide important and economically valuable recreation and tourism resources. They are the most effective way of creating a win for marine conservation and an economic win through sustainable marine recreation and tourism.”

Continue reading “Marine Protected Area definition too loose – Expert reaction

The Latest

In the News

Firstborn females more likely to be overweight, obese – NZ research

Girls who are born the first in their family are more likely to be overweight or obese compared to their younger sisters, according to a new study from New Zealand and Swedish researchers. The conclusions were drawn from a study of more than 13,000 pairs of adult Swedish sisters – the largest study of its […]

Science Alert: Experts Respond

MetService considered for BBC weather – Expert reaction

The BBC has dropped the UK Met Office as its weather forecasting provider and is considering a subsidiary of the New Zealand MetService as an alternative. You can read more on the official announcement from the BBC and the UK Met Office. Over the weekend, the Daily Mail speculated on the potential alternatives: “The BBC […]

Reflections On Science

The Taonga Genome Project on Radio NZ

The director of genetics at Otago University, Peter Dearden, spoke on Radio New Zealand’s Sunday Morning show about his proposal for a taonga genome project to get New Zealand scientists discovering more about the county’s native species, including animals, plants and insects. You can read more about the proposed project in Assoc Prof Dearden’s post […]

Copyright 2015 Science Media Centre (New Zealand)

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy