Ilôt Casy Nouvelle-Calédonie. Photo by Éric Deschaintre on Unsplash

COP31 wraps up as the Pacific faces climate change reality – Expert Reaction

The UN climate conference is wrapping up amid deep divisions on climate action, mounting extreme weather impacts and the challenges facing Pacific nations.

Climate campaigners once again awarded New Zealand for backsliding on climate action, while the NZ government reaffirmed its commitment to the Paris agreement, and support for Pacific communities facing the impacts of climate change.

The SMC asked NZ experts to comment on the key takeaways from COP31. 


Professor Yvonne Underhill-Sem, Māori and Pacific Studies, University of Auckland, comments:

“The ‘Implementation COP’ was also about retaining key global commitments to emissions reduction, the critical role of science, the central importance of oceans, and the special circumstances of Small Island Developing Countries (SIDS).

“Hard working negotiators, politicians and civil society from the Pacific are part of the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) and have been working steadily to hold key commitments such as the following:

  • “Retaining the Paris target of 1.5°C reduction in emissions. Scientific evidence shows that although there has already been an ‘overshoot‘ in this target – about 1.7°C I think – it is still possible to return to the 1.5°C target if developed countries stick to their promises.
  • “Retaining the central role of IPCC in generating the necessary science to inform decision-making. Unbelievably, this was under threat from climate scepticism.
  • “Ocean health is a central part of ensuring the global regulation of climatic systems and therefore sustainable livelihoods globally. It needed to be at the centre of concern of all environmental systems. With recent tragedies in mountain regions due to climate change, it was important to ensure oceans were not overlooked for their fundamental value.

“Small island developing countries are stewards of vast ocean areas, but their economies are hit hardest by climate-induced disaster losses. However, they continue to lead the global climate agenda, and at this COP we saw local solutions that have global benefits, such as innovative financing—notably Niue winning the Earthshot 2026 award—supporting locally led gender-, youth-, and disability-responsive governance, and research.”

Conflict of interest statement: Conflict of interest statement not yet received. 


Dr. Karan Titus, PhD in Renewable Energy Engineering, Postdoctoral Fellow at Civil and Environmental Department, Sustainable Energy Research Group (SERG), University of Canterbury, comments:

“At the forefront of COP31 was the very serious challenge of overshooting the 1.5°C target. Every fraction of overshoot can represent terrible, potentially irreversible, consequences for ecosystems and vulnerable communities. The Pacific is at the heart of these consequences, already facing the realities of climate change. Unfortunately, the Global North has yet to grapple with this, as evidenced by their lack of committed adaptation funds.

“On the mitigation side, renewables and electrification are still facing hurdles from oil-producing countries. This is despite the now many documented cases of renewables bringing about cheap, abundant power and greater prosperity to communities. Even language revolving around the ‘transition away from fossil fuels’ was cut from the most recent draft of the text. The disproportionate power held by these oil-producing countries continues to be antithetical to limiting overshoot of 1.5°C.

“Once overshoot occurs, plateauing emissions through renewables needs to be followed by proactively removing carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere. In this vein, carbon dioxide removal had its first mention in the draft negotiations. This is an important signal to the developers and investors of the burgeoning industry.”

Conflict of interest statement: “No conflicts of interest.”


Professor Tim Naish, Chair of the World Climate Research Programme & Professor of Antarctic Science at Victoria University of Wellington, comments:

“I am writing this on the long flight home to New Zealand, with mixed feelings. COP31 in Antalya drew 92,000 people, the largest climate summit ever held. In its corridors it showed humanity at its best with people from every corner of the world, united by concern for the health of our planet. That gives me hope.

“Then there are the negotiations. As I write, countries are haggling over the final wording of the summit’s main decision. It is full of nice words and good intentions, and unlikely to deliver anything concrete. In its latest nine-page version, the words “fossil fuels” do not appear at all.

“This summit was billed as the “implementation COP”. Yet it has delivered none of the goals set by its co-presidents, Türkiye and Australia. There is nothing concrete on transitioning away from fossil fuels, the single most important lever we have.

“On money, the picture is no better. The goal going in was to triple adaptation finance to US$120 billion a year. That figure is now off the table, even though adaptation needs in the Global South alone are estimated at around US$500 billion a year. Talks on a just transition mechanism made no progress.

“Even the one concrete number still in play, a goal for clean electricity to supply 35 per cent of the world’s final energy use by 2035, has not been agreed.

“I went to Antalya as Chair of the World Climate Research Programme. My job, alongside other UN agencies, was to make sure the best available science underpins the negotiations. The IPCC delivers its major assessments every six or seven years. In between, UNEP’s annual Emissions Gap and Adaptation Gap reports and the WMO’s State of the Global Climate report show how far off track we are.

“What I did not expect was how hard that science would be fought. Saudi Arabia, India and Russia, and at times China, used every tactic to delay, dilute, discredit and obscure robust, rigorously peer-reviewed findings. Three of them became flashpoints.

“The first is the most stark. At current emissions, the remaining carbon budget for 1.5°C will be used up in three to four years. The world will reach 1.5°C of long-term warming around 2029–2030, breaching the lower limit of the Paris Agreement. For small island states and the least developed countries, that line is existential and non-negotiable.

“For the first time, the idea of “overshoot” was widely discussed: a pathway where warming rises above 1.5°C and is later brought back down. It split the room. Many fear petrostates will use it as licence to keep producing fossil fuels, betting on carbon removal at a scale that does not yet exist. Small island states have rightly refused any backsliding. The latest draft still speaks of keeping 1.5°C within reach, but leans heavily on carbon capture.

“The second flashpoint was an attempt to wave away the annual science altogether. Saudi Arabia, India and Russia objected to citing any findings from outside the IPCC process, including the WMO’s State of the Global Climate report and UNEP’s report on overshooting 1.5°C. They dismissed this work as “grey literature”. Meetings and press conferences were hastily convened, where I and other scientists behind these reports set out just how robust they are.

“The third, and the biggest fight of the summit, was over the timing of the IPCC’s next major assessment, its Seventh Assessment Report. The same countries are accused of pushing to delay it until 2029. That would miss the 2028 Global Stocktake, the moment the world measures its progress against the Paris goals, which the report exists to inform.

“Dozens of European, African and Pacific nations want the report delivered in time. The chair of the small island states’ bloc called any delay “unjustifiable”. The Marshall Islands envoy called it a “travesty”. They are right. Pushing back the science until after the stocktake is a way of making sure the reckoning has nothing to measure against.

“Credit where it is due. Bus delays of several hours aside, our Turkish hosts laid on an impressive venue, and the city of Antalya warmly embraced the world.

“But a summit’s worth will be measured by its outcome. Weigh the enormous cost, the carbon footprint of flying in 92,000 people, and a final text that backslides on fossil fuels. I cannot help asking whether this process has had its day, and whether a new model is needed.

“That question grows more urgent as multilateral institutions and international cooperation come under severe strain. The physics will not wait for the negotiators. If the system built to act on the science cannot even agree to hear it on time, we must find one that will.”

Conflict of interest statement: “Tim Naish is Chair of the World Climate Research Programme.”